The Secret Keeper

Image © 2004 by TikiGeek

A Prisoner of Azkaban musical (in progress) based on Lucy Simon's and Marsha Norman's 1991 musical The Secret Garden by Literary Luminary

The Prison Out to Sea
All My Fault
Three Boys on the Express
I Hear Someone…
Last Moments
Come and Join Me for Tea
It's a Shame
Show Me the Charm
The Patronus Charm
If To Hogsmeade I Could Go
Letter Unsent
He Should Have Had
Explanation
Regrets and Blame

Copyright 2004, 2005 by Literary Luminary

The Prison Out to Sea

To the tune of The House Upon the Hill

SCENE: On a tiny island in the North Sea, Azkaban Prison stands, dark and foreboding. Lily and James (playing the Dreamers*) look on it sorrowfully.

JAMES:
Far out to sea is a lonely prison
Walls and sea's fury bind it
And only the lost
In guilt and fury ever find it.

LILY:
Naught will cease their souls' torment
Their screaming or their crying.
They call out, raging,
As they are slowly dying.

But one held there is innocent
He would never harm or kill;
Yet no one listens,
And he waits still.

JAMES:
His time to flee is coming soon
I know that he will make it
I gave him a task to do
And he will undertake it.

There he sits and bides his time
Burning with slow fury
At the rat who sent him there
Acting as judge and jury.

LILY:
The Dementors are still drifting
But he isn't driven mad-
He knows his time is coming,
And justice will be had.

*For those of you unfamiliar with the original play and wondering what in blazes James and Lily are doing in this scene, the Dreamers are the spirits of the dead. They watch over the living characters, occasionally commenting on their actions (similar in some ways to the classical Greek chorus).

All My Fault

To the tune of There's a Girl

SCENE: Flashback -- In the aftermath of Halloween, 1981, Sirius discovers the ruins of Godric's Hollow, and blames his own folly for James and Lily's deaths just before going after Peter.

SIRIUS:
It must be a dream;
It cannot be true
How can they be gone?
I was such a fool.

How could I have placed
My trust, so undeserved
In a trait'rous rat?
This is all my fault.

There's a baby who's left crying,
There's a baby left alone;
My godson, who's now orphaned
In a house that's not a home
In a house that's not a home.

Three Boys on the Express

To the tune of A Girl in the Valley

SCENE: Remus, observing the Trio's camaraderie, reminisces on his own childhood friends.

REMUS:
Three boys I met on the Express,
Three boys I hardly knew,
Three boys I met on the Express
Befriended me.

I had been sitting all alone,
Habitually solitary,
Then James, Sirius and Peter
All began knocking.

From the door
They called out quite loudly,
"Can't we please sit here;
Everywhere else is now full?"

I let them-
Well, why not permit it?
Just harmless boys,
And eas'ly ignored.

But James, Sirius and Peter
Three boys, who I would soon see,
Three boys, who all were determined,
Befriended me.

What wouldn't I give
Just to see them.
All I would ask is simply-
Simply "Why?"

"Why'd you leave me,
Why'd you betray us,
Why am I alone now?
When

We were
Once un-i, once un-i,
Once united?"

Three boys I met on the Express,
Three boys-who well I knew…
Three boys, all of them now fallen…
Once, they loved me.

I Hear Someone…

To the tune of I Heard Someone Crying

SCENE: Harry, Ginny, Neville, and Lupin reflect on the Dementor-induced horrors recollected on the Hogwarts Express.

HARRY:
I hear someone crying,
Who, though, could it be?
I think that it's my mother, crying out for me,
Pleading that I might live, even if she has to die-
When Dementors come too near, I hear my mother's cries…

GINNY:
I hear someone laughing,
Who else would it be?
I can hear Tom Riddle, reaching into me,
Mocking all my secrets, my dreams, my every choice-
When Dementors come too near, I hear Tom Riddle's voice.

BOTH:
They are horrid monsters, then, to force remembrance of our pasts.
They are horrid monsters-how I hope their spell here will not last…

NEVILLE:
I hear someone screaming,
Voices from long ago.
Voices that I long to hear, but will never really know.
My mother and my father-I can hear them shriek with pain.
When Dementors come too near, I recall that night again…

ALL THREE:
They force us into dreaming of
The terrors that we once endured.
Our joy pouring into them-we need release; aid, we implore!

LUPIN:
I hear someone crying,
To me, the voice is known.
The cries that I am hearing-who else's, but my own?
I hear my own crying, on the night my friends all died…
When Dementors come too near-how bitterly I cried!

I hear someone crying,
Three children, lost in pain,
Wondering desperately if they will know joy again-
I know what they're feeling; I will come to their defense:
Dementors, leave this place-I now end your pretense!

Last Moments

To the tune of Final Storm

SCENE: In the Hospital Wing following the Gryffindor vs. Hufflepuff match, Harry has nightmares of his parents' last moments. (Note: The shades of Voldemort's previous victims will function as an unseen-but-audible Chorus)

CHORUS:
Late on this Halloween night,
Voldemort draws near your door,
Prophecy causing him fright,
Murder is what he's there for…
James and Lily Potter,
Oh, beware…

VOLDEMORT:
Three times you've defied me and lived;
Now it's your time to die.
Your baby won't be any threat to me;
I've been warned by clever spy…

CHORUS:
Oh, hurry; he's at the door!

JAMES:
Lily, Harry, go;
Voldemort I'll slow;
Fidelius is no more.

LILY (simultaneous with James):
Oh, our doomsday has come;
We have been betrayed!

Only one re-
Course now…

JAMES (simultaneous with Lily's last line):
I will defend to my last breath…

Lily rushes up the stairs to the nursery, searching for means of escape but finding none. Finally, she stands before Harry's cot. He begins to cry

LILY:
Don't cry, baby;
Harm won't come to you.
You'll survive this, my
Son…

Cut to front door, where Voldemort has disarmed James. Simultaneous with Lily's last two lines, he gloats

VOLDEMORT:
You've fought well, James Potter;
Just not well enough.

His Killing Curse dispatches James, and he moves on to his real quarry. Cut to nursery, where Lily is still standing in front of Harry. She continues to comfort him

LILY:
Hush, little one.

Cut to Voldemort, advancing up the stairs in classic horror movie style-i.e., very slowly. Simultaneous with Lily, he sings

VOLDEMORT:
Victory's near.

Cut back to nursery. For the purposes of this filk-I'm invoking creative license-Lily has cast a protective charm over Harry with advance knowledge of its effect

LILY:
The charm that I've spun
Will let you see through
This night…

Cut to Voldemort, just outside the nursery, who has conveniently missed hearing Lily. Simultaneous with her, he sings

VOLDEMORT:
I will
Void seer's
Warning…

He enters, wand drawn, and addresses Lily

Stand aside, foolish girl
And I'll let you live;
It's only your son I want.

Just give the boy to me,
And I'll let you live;
You're not the one I hunt.
Your husband is dead;
And soon your baby as well.

LILY:
Please, not Harry! Please, not Harry!
Mercy I beg you show!
Anything I'll give,
If you'll let him live!
In his place, I'll gladly go!

Voice calls out, beginning to break through the nightmare

Harry!

VOLDEMORT /(VOICE):
Then Avada… (Harry!)

VOLDEMORT:
….Kedavra!

Come and Join Me for Tea

To the tune of The Girl I Mean to Be

SCENE: Harry, unable to go to Hogsmeade, joins Professor Lupin for tea and conversation.

LUPIN:
Harry, come in; you seem to be
Alone and needing company.
Come have a chat, perhaps some tea-
But mind the Grindylow tank.

HARRY:
Thanks, Professor; I think I will;
My friends are both in Hogsmeade still
(I wish I that I could go, but lack
The required permission).

LUPIN:
You seem to have some worry on your mind,
If you would tell me?

HARRY: You stopped me from trying 'gainst the Boggart- Why thus expel me?

LUPIN:
I thought that if you took your place,
It would have worn Voldemort's face;
Though clearly I was wrong, it seemed
Quite prudent at the time.

Owing to a need to fit more subject matter into this filk, I'll pause here to let you all cue up the music again. Ready? Good. And we resume…

HARRY:
I thought of Voldemort at first,
But fear the Dementors the worst.

LUPIN:
So your worst fear is fear itself…
That is very wise, Harry.

He is about to go on, but is interrupted - right on schedule - by Snape, bearing a goblet of Wolfsbane.

SNAPE:
You ought to drink that right away-
It won't profit you to delay.
I have more in my cauldron when the next
Dose is required.

Exit Snape

HARRY (thinking):
I think, with eye of newt and slime of slug,
(For he is vicious)
Snape's concocted some truly deadly drug,
Not one nutritious.

Despite Harry's not-very-subtle attempts to hint to him that Snape may, in fact, be trying to poison him, Lupin drinks the potion, then bids Harry farewell

LUPIN:
Well, Harry, I have work to do-
And, most likely, so do you;
But thank you for a pleasant time,
And for your company.

It's a Shame

To the tune of It's a Maze

SCENE: Harry rushes into the Defense Against the Dark Arts classroom and is dismayed to find Snape has taken his mild-mannered mentor's place behind the desk. Furthermore, Snape has made some interesting changes to the lesson plan.

SNAPE:
Lupin's ill, so I'll teach
There's a need; I will fill it.
Potter, sit. Not a sound!
Insubordination? I'll kill it.

Today you will learn how to recognize
A werewolf-mere child's play.
Lupin's been lenient; you'll work hard today.
Werewolf, true wolf-differences?

Miss Granger, five points; your hand wasn't raised.
Tormenting students, thus I spend my days.
Mr. Weasley, detention-infirmary.
That's how my Defense class goes.

HARRY:
Oh, how I wish that Lupin were well.
There's no denying that Snape's class is hell.
He's a sadist with a greasy-haired head
"Fantastic Beasts" went completely unread.

HERMIONE:
Everyone knows Kappas are native to Japan
But there's no telling this man.
He thinks they're Mongolian beasts
I have just one retort: not in the least!

SNAPE:
Lost your minds? No surprise;
I will open your eyes.
Werewolves are bloodthirsty
And won't show you mercy.

(It's a shame, this class; its ignorance is
Almost too much to abide.
But I'll see this through, so they'll have a clue
To the secret Lupin hides.)

A good teacher knows how the lesson goes
How the students wail when their grades are Fail
To assign long essays and let them rail
As resentment climbs.
Act impervious
Test them when it's time.
That's how my Defense class goes.

Show Me the Charm

To the tune of Show Me the Key

SCENE: Harry, feeling he needs help to combat the influence of the Dementors on him, appeals to Professor Lupin.

HARRY (hesitant):
I…

LUPIN (prompting):
You?

HARRY:
I need help.

LUPIN:
You need my help?
Then is there something that's the matter? What is it?

HARRY:
The Dementors.
Why do they affect me so badly?
Am I just weak?

LUPIN:
Certainly not.
It has nothing to do with weakness.

HARRY:
Then can you show me
How to fight against them?
Show me the charm?

LUPIN (contemplative):
Show you the charm…
I don't claim to be expert
And that charm's fiendishly difficult;
Are you quite sure you can manage?
It's far beyond O.W.L. standard.

HARRY:
I have to try.

LUPIN:
So you will try.
If you're willing, I will help you.

HARRY:
Thanks so much, Professor;
I promise to give it my best shot-
I'll give it my all.

LUPIN (spoken):
Indeed, Harry.

HARRY:
You're a Professor knows his craft;
I'll trust you, then, to teach
A charm to me to keep me from
Dementors' chilling reach.
I'll not falter and fall from skies,
Or fail the Snitch to catch,
Since you'll show to me a charm
That will keep me in the match.
The Quidditch Cup we must win;
Gryffindor, so it appears,
Has not been recipient
For so many, many years.
Captain Wood, his heart's set on it,
My team I dare not fail,
For if Dementors cause me distress,
I fear they'd me assail.

So, this charm…

LUPIN:
The Patronus.

HARRY:
Will keep all Dementors far from me.
I'm glad you'll teach me-

LUPIN (interjecting):
After the holiday.

HARRY:
Teach me the charm.

HARRY/(LUPIN):
Teach me (I'll teach) the charm.

Harry leaves. Lupin marvels at Harry's willingness to undertake something so difficult.

LUPIN (contemplative):
He's certainly determined.
Will it be enough? We'll see.
He has talent; perhaps he will
Surprise me.

The Patronus Charm

To the tune of Come Spirit, Come Charm

SCENE: In the DADA office, Remus coaches Harry in the casting of the Patronus Charm. James and Lily (playing the Dreamers) watch and encourage their son.

REMUS (spoken):
The Patronus Charm
Will guard you from harm;
Dementors will it fell
To keep you safe and well.

(Sung) A mem'ry you'll need
To help you succeed
One that evokes joy
Guardian to deploy.

HARRY:
Guardian far above Called up from on high,
Charge Dementors down,
Their powers deny.
Shield me from terrors
That dwell in my past;
Patronus Charm
I prepare to cast.

JAMES/LILY (SUNG THRICE):
Come, Patronus Charm
To guard him from harm
Oh, magical spell,
Please protect him well!

If To Hogsmeade I Could Go

To the tune of If I Had a Fine White Horse

SCENE: Harry expresses his disappointment that he cannot accompany Ron and Hermione to Hogsmeade. They commiserate, but leave without him nonetheless. Harry thinks he'll never see the village-until Fred and George Weasley give him a very valuable gift.

HARRY:
If to Hogsmeade I could go
I'd visit Honeydukes today
And eat sweets till my stomach felt
Quite ready to give way.
I'd sample Fizzing Whizbees, Ice
Mice, Sugar Quills and such.

HERMIONE:
But what's there to do in
a candy shop?
It seems to me not much.

HARRY:
If to Hogsmeade I could go,
I'd visit the joke shop today.
They say that Zonko's features tricks
To take your breath away.
I'd stock up on Dungbombs and
Frogspawn soap and such.

RON:
But we'll bring you stuff back from Zonko's, so
You are not missing much.

HERMIONE:
Besides, you know it's important to
Keep you away from Black!
Harry, we both know he'll get at you
If caution you should lack!

They leave. Harry resumes his little bout of self-pity.

HARRY:
If to Hogsmeade I could go
I'd enjoy my friends' company.
But since I'm the Boy-Who-Lived
I'll have no such luxury.
If only the Dursleys
Weren't my appointed wardens
I'd be able to visit shops;
My horizons broaden.

As though on cue, Fred and George pull Harry into a deserted classroom and explain the workings of the great and glorious Marauder's Map.

FRED AND GEORGE:
We happened upon this one day
Hidden inside Filch's drawer
We stole it right away from him
And rules troubled
Us nevermore.

If to Hogsmeade you would go
Then tap the Map with your wand; say
"I solemnly swear I'm up
To no good" and you'll be on
Your way. Remember to clear it,
A "Mischief Managed" does
The trick. If you should happen to see
The passage guarded by the tree
And are not killed by its fury
Then come and tell my dearest twin
And me.

Letter Unsent

To the tune of The Letter Song

SCENE: Remus writes a letter to James and Lily, telling them about Harry.

REMUS:
D-E-A-R James and Lily,
How are you?
I'm fine,
At least as fine as I can be.
I miss you.

Harry looks so much like you, Prongs,
But Lily, he has your eyes.
And it almost hurts to see him.
I miss you.

How I wish you could be with him
Of your son, you'd be so proud.
I want to tell him everything
But I know that's disallowed.

I've taught him the Patronus Charm
To keep Dementors all at bay.
He has it corporeal, Prongs,
In your image, I must say.

Oh, dear friends,
James and Lily,
Oh, if only you could see
How well your boy is growing up.
I miss you.

Forever,
Sincerely,
Your friend,
Moony

He Should Have Had

To the tune of A Bit of Earth

Remus reflects on Harry's childhood and considers should-haves, what-ifs, and might-have-beens.

REMUS:
A proper home.
He should have had a proper home.
His child's needs
They went ignored.
He was unloved, He was unwanted:
Yes, I see.
His family,
His mother's sister and her lot,
They would not care:
For he is "strange",
And so affection
Though desired, was not shared.

He should have had
James, yes, and Lily;
Brother, sister-
Loving arms.
He should have known
His heritage;
Grown up seeing
Spells, magic charms.

He should have love,
This surely is in my power to give
But I can't tell
The secrets that
Cannot now live.

If Black had been loyal,
What now would life be?
Could our pack of six have
Remained close-knit, family?
If only I could turn back time,
Prevent the whole tragedy,
Make them see
Who the traitor would be…
But I can't. And
We are alone.

A proper home.
I would give him this, if I could.
But I don't dare
I cannot trust
What I become
When full moon rises in the air.
I want so much to tell him all, to
Love him just as he should be…
Yet that path's barred by the curse that's
Forever within me.

He should have had a proper home.
He should have had his family.

Explanation

To the tune of Quartet

SCENE: In the Shrieking Shack, Remus and Sirius endeavor to explain the truth of the latter's innocence to the skeptical Trio.

REMUS (spoken):
Sirius, you do owe them all an explanation-
Even I don't understand everything!
And Harry-Harry simply must know the truth!

SIRIUS (spoken):
Fine-you'll explain; then we'll kill the rat-
I've waited years…

REMUS:
All of this begins with me,
Lycanthropic since youth.
Listen closely to our tale,
And understand the truth.
When I was at Hogwarts, my three best friends
Couldn't fail my plight to see.

SIRIUS:
For every month, he would disappear,
And return, ill and in pain.
As for his welfare we did fear,
A solution we ascertained.

REMUS:
James, Sirius and Peter,
Animagi became.
They joined me on full moon nights,
And helped to keep me sane.
Terrible ordeal was
Greatly eased-and even became a game!

But though insep'rable in our schooldays,
The First War cut our bonds, and then apart we strayed.
Worst of all, poor Peter Pettigrew
Became the servant of
Lord You-Know-Who.

SIRIUS (spoken):
The rat always was quite stupid. But we never
Thought he could be a spy-who would give him that much credit?
We suspected each other, Remus and I, while the
Real betrayer watched.

REMUS (spoken):
That's all in the past, Padfoot, forgiven.
Now, I think it's time we offered
A bit of solid proof. Ron, give me the rat, please.

After some coaxing, Ron obliges. Remus and Sirius draw their wands

On one…two… and three!

Wormtail reverts to human shape

REMUS/PETER (Sung):
Hello, it seems that you have/My dear old
A lot to answer for/Friend Moony
James and Lily you betrayed/Don't kill me
Gave them to Voldemort!/Have mercy!

SIRIUS/PETER:
I suffered for twelve years/Sirius
For your crimes/I'm sorry!
Now it's time/Please, listen!
For you to pay!/Dark Lord forced me!

PETER/SIRIUS:
I was never strong like you
And Remus and James/Traitor!
When the Dark Lord/You turncoat!
He did approach me/Betrayer!
Had no choice/You fool!
No other option I could see/You killed them, Wormtail!

I/I won't forgive that-
Could/They were my fam'ly
Not save/Wormtail, I swear
Them/Your life ends tonight!

REMUS/SIRIUS/PETER/HARRY:
He was our friend once,/-/-/He betrayed them
But a traitor/-/-/Mum, Dad
He became/-/-/His fault
And destroyed us/James and Lily,/I'm so sorry/Justice
All./Please forgive me;/I didn't mean/Will be done now.
And now we/-/-/-/

Will avenge/I was wrong/To kill you/And I will
The wrong done/To tell/-/Know that
Years ago./You to switch Keepers/-/The traitor has paid.
James, Lily/I never realized/My death/Never should have strayed
I'm sorry;/He would/Soon will come;/From Light.
I should have/Betray/-/Can I
Known that Sirius/You and the Order./I deserve/Let them both do this?
He was loyal./Now/-/No.
-/We will/-/I can't.
Wormtail dies./He dies./Nothing less./Dad would
-/Remus, help me!/-/Never want
-/Now we'll kill him./-/Them to be killers
-/Now, together, we will kill him./ -/So he'd show the traitor mercy.

Music ends. Just as Remus and Sirius are preparing to dispatch Wormtail, Harry stops them…and you all know the rest.

Regrets and Blame

To the tune of Where in the World

SCENE: In the Shrieking Shack, Sirius and Remus attempt to explain to the skeptical trio the events that occurred twelve years prior, Remus acting rational and Sirius blaming himself and Pettigrew in turns.

SIRIUS:
Twelve years ago, the Charm was cast
All according to our plans
I was to be Secret-Keeper
But the Secret then changed hands;
Given into Wormtail's care
Our confidence betrayed.
Against dearest James and Lily
Dark forces were arrayed.

How could I have trusted a traitor,
Suspicious of a faithful friend
Setting death and pain in motion
Bringing sweet days to an end?

REMUS:
You couldn't have known the betrayal planned
Nor tuned back the Dark Lord's curse.
Why blame yourself when you are not at fault
Your imagined guilt all the worse?

Their blood on Voldemort's hands alone
Culpability with this rat.
No fault ever lay with you
Oh, how I wish you could understand that!

SIRIUS:
I should have been the Secret-Keeper; I
Would have borne it to the grave.
How can you forgive, how can you forgive
When both their lives I could have saved?
Lives I could have…


Harry Potter the Musical(s)

Return Home